A Slice of Heaven: The Best Pizzas in Greenville

November, 23rd, 2022 | By GVLtasty

From Wood-Fired to New York Style: Your Ultimate Greenville Pizza Guide

Uncovering the Greenville pizza scene can feel like an exciting treasure hunt. Are you into the heavenly crunch of a thin crust, or do you find solace in the sumptuous embrace of deep-dish delights? At the heart of it all, perhaps you're longing for that classic, foldable NY-style slice? Greenville offers a myriad of artisanal pizzas to satiate your cravings and lure you away from generic, mass-produced alternatives. For an unforgettable mobile pizza experience, follow Local Pie Pizza Co. (@localpiepizzaco) and track their food truck. Our favorite traditional pizzerias are listed below, but if you think we're missing some hidden gems, don't hesitate to slide into our DMs.

Bada Bing Pizzeria

Delight in the authentic flavors of New York-style pizza right here in Greenville at Bada Bing Pizzeria (@badabing_pizzeria). From a crust that valiantly supports fresh, generous toppings to their tempting lunch specials, every pizza lover's dream is realized here.

Basilico Pizzeria & Italian

Despite a mouthwatering menu of Italian cuisine, it's near impossible not to be lured by a 16” pie every time at Basilico (@basilicogreenville). Prepare for a culinary journey underpinned by fantastic pizza and a charming, friendly staff.

Belladina’s Pizzeria

Two decades of Leccese family expertise culminate in Belladina's (@belladinas) exquisite thin-crust NY-style pizza, featuring fresh ingredients and exceptional service. This pizzeria is testament to the fact that great Italian food is timeless.

Coastal Crust Greenville

With a grand wood-fired oven at the helm, Coastal Crust (@coastalcrustgreenville) serves pizzas that strike the perfect balance of crisp and chewy. Revel in the cool ambiance and choice of indoor or outdoor seating while you savor each slice.

D’Allesandro’s Pizza

Discover the joy of thin-crust pizza, a plethora of toppings, friendly service, and chilled beer at D'Allesandro's (@dalspizzagvl). This welcoming venue also features an entertaining play yard for kids, making it a hit for the whole family.

Frankie’s NY Pizza

Frankie’s NY Pizza guarantees a taste of the Big Apple in every slice. Their secret lies in using Grande cheese for their mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes for their sauce. With fresh dough hand-stretched daily, this is your go-to for an authentic NY-style pizza experience.

Paisano’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

Enter a world of delightful Italian food in a cozy atmosphere at Paisano's (@paisanospelham). Their pizzas may not be super thin, but they more than make up for it with a generous layer of cheese and vibrant fresh toppings.

Pangaea Brewing Co.

Surprise! Pangaea (@pangaeabrewing) is not just a brewery. Their pizza rivals some of the best in Greenville. Wash down each flavorful bite with one of their masterfully brewed beers for an unforgettable gastronomic adventure.

Pizza Parcheggio

Don't be fooled by the carry-out only model, because Pizza Parcheggio is delivering some of Greenville's finest thin-crust pizzas, right from the underground. They pride themselves on serving well-done, classic pies in a limited quantity, making each day a race for the best pizza in town. With a first come, first served policy, Pizza Parcheggio adds an exciting, exclusive element to the pizza scene in Greenville. Embrace the chase and treat yourself to a pie that truly stands out in the crowd.

Pizza Purists

For the discerning pizza aficionado, Pizza Purists (@pizza_purists) is the place to be. Thin crust, fresh toppings, and unique custom pies come together to create a pizza experience that stays true to the art. Don't miss out on The Yankee, a fan favorite.

Sidewall Pizza Company

Sidewall (@sidewallpizza) shines through with its handcrafted pizzas, fresh salads, and house-made ice cream across several Upstate locations. Dine in or al fresco and enjoy their fresh toppings, perfect crust, and unique pizza offerings.


At Tacozzini (@tacozzini), a harmonious fusion of Mexican and Italian cuisine unfolds, presenting you with unique, mouthwatering pizza choices. Enjoy the serene indoor setting or the charming outdoor patio while you discover the delights on their menu.

Todaro Pizza GVL

Todaro Pizza (@todaropizzagvl) offers a classic thin-crust pizza that manages to stay crispy while maintaining a delightful chew. Complement your pizza experience with their wide selection of drinks, and enjoy the abundant seating, indoors or on their sprawling downtown patio.

World Piece

World Piece (@worldpiecegvl) brings the rare delight of authentic deep-dish pizza to Greenville. They also serve up excellent hand-tossed pizzas and indulgent garlic knots. Pair your meal with a cold brew from their fantastic neighbor, Liability Beer.

Pangaea Brewing Company

Pangaea Brewing Company

Location Area Icon Area: Unity Park

Cuisine Icon Brewery Pizza

Tag Icon Outdoor Seating Dogs Allowed Open Sunday

Pizza Parcheggio

Pizza Parcheggio

Location Area Icon Area: Woodruff Rd

Cuisine Icon Pizza

Tag Icon Open Sunday Lunch Dinner

Share This Post

< Meet Chef Joe Cash Meet Chef Drew Erickson >