A Slice of Heaven: Your Ultimate Guide to the Best Pizza in Greenville

May, 13th, 2024 | By GVLtasty

From Wood-Fired Wonders to Classic New York-Style Slices, Discover the Top Pizza Spots in Greenville for Every Craving and Occasion

Greenville, known for its thriving food scene, is home to some of the most delectable pizza joints in the region. Uncovering the Greenville pizza scene can feel like an exciting treasure hunt, with a myriad of artisanal pizzas to satiate your cravings and lure you away from generic, mass-produced alternatives. Whether you're into the heavenly crunch of a thin crust, the sumptuous embrace of deep-dish delights, or longing for that classic, foldable NY-style slice, Greenville has something to offer for every pizza lover.

In this comprehensive guide, we'll take you on a tantalizing journey through the top pizza places in Greenville, each offering a unique experience and unforgettable flavors. From wood-fired wonders to authentic New York-style slices, get ready to embark on a mouthwatering adventure as we explore the best pizza in Greenville, one slice at a time.

Bada Bing Pizzeria

Step into Bada Bing Pizzeria and be transported to the streets of New York City, where the authentic flavors of classic NY-style pizza reign supreme. This beloved Greenville spot is known for its perfectly crisp crust that effortlessly supports an abundance of fresh, generous toppings. With tempting lunch specials and a warm, inviting atmosphere, Bada Bing Pizzeria is a haven for pizza lovers seeking a true taste of the Big Apple right here in the heart of Greenville.

Basilico Pizzeria & Italian

Despite a mouthwatering menu of Italian cuisine, it's near impossible not to be lured by a 16” pie every time at Basilico (@basilicogreenville). Prepare for a culinary journey underpinned by fantastic pizza and a charming, friendly staff.

Belladina's Pizzeria

Belladina's Pizzeria has earned a reputation as the go-to spot for pizza aficionados in search of the perfect crust. This family-owned establishment takes pride in serving up game-changing Detroit-style and Chicago-style pizzas that will transport your taste buds to the Windy City. The authentic flavors, combined with the friendly staff and engaging conversations, make every visit to Belladina's a memorable experience. Whether you're a fan of deep-dish or prefer a crispy, thin crust, Belladina's Pizzeria is sure to impress.

Coastal Crust

Coastal Crust is a culinary gem that has taken Greenville by storm with its exceptional wood-fired pizzas. Each pie boasts a perfectly balanced crust that is both crispy and thin, topped with an array of fresh, high-quality ingredients. The West Village pizza is a true showstopper, featuring a flavor-rich crust that will leave you craving more. Pair your pizza with a selection from their excellent wine list and start your meal with a delightful Caesar salad or the sweet and savory Burrata appetizer for an unforgettable dining experience.

D'Allesandro's Pizza

At D'Allesandro's Pizza, you'll find a delightful combination of thin-crust pizza, an extensive selection of toppings, friendly service, and a laid-back atmosphere perfect for enjoying a chilled beer. This welcoming venue goes above and beyond to cater to families, offering an entertaining play yard for kids to enjoy while the adults savor their delicious slices. With its commitment to quality ingredients and a relaxed vibe, D'Allesandro's Pizza is a favorite among Greenville locals and visitors alike.

Frankie’s NY Pizza

Frankie’s NY Pizza guarantees a taste of the Big Apple in every slice. Their secret lies in using Grande cheese for their mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes for their sauce. With fresh dough hand-stretched daily, this is your go-to for an authentic NY-style pizza experience.


Limoncello, a charming Italian restaurant in Greenville, offers a delightful dining experience that extends beyond its delectable pizza offerings. While their warm, tasty pizza toast serves as the perfect accompaniment to the mouthwatering spinach and artichoke dip, Limoncello's menu boasts a range of impressive dishes. The creamy Tuscan chicken, served hearty and full of flavor, and the highly recommended shrimp Alfredo are just a few examples of the culinary delights that await diners. The attentive and helpful staff enhance the overall experience, ensuring that every visit to Limoncello is top-notch. To cap off the evening, indulge in one of their fancy cocktails and savor a scoop of their delicious gelato for a sweet and satisfying finish.

Local Pie Pizza Co.

For a truly unique pizza experience, look no further than Local Pie Pizza Co., a food truck sensation that has taken Greenville by storm. Owners Cory and Braden have mastered the art of crafting incredible pizzas that rival even the best brick-and-mortar restaurants. With a diverse menu featuring an array of toppings, cheeses, and bases, Local Pie Pizza Co. caters to every taste, from classic combinations to innovative creations like the crowd-pleasing BBQ chicken pizza. Their attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction make Local Pie Pizza Co. the ultimate choice for exceptional pizza on the go.

Mellow Mushroom Greenville

Mellow Mushroom Greenville is a haven for pizza enthusiasts seeking creative and flavorful pies in a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere. Don't miss out on the Holy Shiitake pizza, a standout dish that bursts with umami goodness. Start your meal with the irresistible pretzel bites appetizer, and enjoy the friendly service and great vibes that make Mellow Mushroom a beloved fixture in the Greenville pizza scene. While the wait times may be a bit longer, the fresh, delicious pizza is well worth the anticipation.

Myles Pizza Pub

For a truly unique pizza experience that breaks away from the norm, head to Myles Pizza Pub. This family-owned establishment takes pride in serving up distinctive Midwest-style pizzas that are generously topped with a tangy special sauce and cooked to perfection, resulting in a satisfying char on the edges and a well-done top. The hearty portions ensure that a single slice is enough to satisfy even the heartiest of appetites. Beyond their signature pizzas, Myles Pizza Pub offers a range of delectable sides and desserts, such as the stuffed breadsticks with cheese, the mouthwatering avocado goat cheese beet salad, and the irresistible cherry cheesecake cookie fresh from the oven.

Paisano’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

Enter a world of delightful Italian food in a cozy atmosphere at Paisano's (@paisanospelham). Their pizzas may not be super thin, but they more than make up for it with a generous layer of cheese and vibrant fresh toppings.

Pangaea Brewing Company

Pangaea Brewing Company is more than just a haven for beer enthusiasts; it's also a hidden gem for pizza lovers. Nestled next to Unity Park and the Swamp Rabbit Trail, this inviting spot offers a beautiful atmosphere with both cozy indoor seating and sun-drenched outdoor picnic tables. Their exceptional pizzas are crafted to perfectly complement their top-notch beer selection, creating a harmonious pairing that keeps patrons coming back for more. The friendly and attentive staff, like the beloved CJ, go above and beyond to ensure that every visit to Pangaea Brewing Company is a delightful and memorable experience.

Pizza Parcheggio

Prepare to be pleasantly surprised by Pizza Parcheggio, a carry-out only establishment that's serving up some of the finest thin-crust pizzas in Greenville. This hidden gem prides itself on offering a limited quantity of well-done, classic pies each day, creating an air of exclusivity and anticipation among pizza enthusiasts. With a first-come, first-served policy, securing a Pizza Parcheggio pie feels like winning a delicious prize. The focus on quality ingredients and traditional techniques shines through in every bite, making Pizza Parcheggio a must-try for anyone seeking an exceptional pizza experience.

Sidewall Pizza Company

Sidewall Pizza Company has carved out a special place in the hearts of Greenville pizza lovers with its commitment to offering delicious, handcrafted pies that cater to a variety of dietary needs. What sets Sidewall apart is their inclusion of plant-based mozzarella cheese, a game-changer for vegetarians and those with lactose intolerance who often struggle to find satisfying pizza options. Their signature thin crust boasts a perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness, complemented by a tasty sauce and an array of fresh toppings. Beyond their exceptional pizzas, Sidewall's fresh, flavorful salads and house-made ice cream add to the overall dining experience, while the warm, welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff make every visit a true delight.


At Tacozzini (@tacozzini), a harmonious fusion of Mexican and Italian cuisine unfolds, presenting you with unique, mouthwatering pizza choices. Enjoy the serene indoor setting or the charming outdoor patio while you discover the delights on their menu.

Todaro Pizza GVL

Todaro Pizza (@todaropizzagvl) offers a classic thin-crust pizza that manages to stay crispy while maintaining a delightful chew. Complement your pizza experience with their wide selection of drinks, and enjoy the abundant seating, indoors or on their sprawling downtown patio.

Greenville's pizza scene is a vibrant tapestry of flavors, styles, and experiences. From the classic New York-style slices at Bada Bing Pizzeria to the innovative creations at Mellow Mushroom, and the wood-fired perfection at Coastal Crust, there's a pizza for every palate and occasion. Whether you're a local looking to explore new favorites or a visitor eager to taste the best of Greenville's pizza offerings, this guide will help you navigate the city's top pizza spots with ease.

So, gather your friends, family, or that special someone, and embark on a pizza-loving adventure through Greenville. With each bite, you'll discover the passion, creativity, and dedication that goes into crafting the perfect slice. Don't forget to share your favorite pizza moments with us and let us know if we've missed any hidden gems. Happy pizza hunting!

Check Out GVLtasty's Pizza Listings Below:

Share This Post

< Elevate Your Greenville Food and Drink Experience with our Raves and Favs Top 10 Greenville Restaurants You Must Try >